Shop most valuable nickels

Sponsored
$35.00
1958 D Nickel Error
Etsy
$35.00
1958 D Nickel Error
Etsy
$799.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel No Date
eBay
Free shipping
$799.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel No Date
eBay
Free shipping
$1,750.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,750.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Indian Head / Buffalo 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Indian Head / Buffalo 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$399.99
1964 Jefferson Five Cent Nickel Denver D Mint Mark
eBay
$399.99
1964 Jefferson Five Cent Nickel Denver D Mint Mark
eBay
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (518894069), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (518894069), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$900.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$900.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$500.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
$500.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
$139.00
1942 Wartime Nickel
Etsy
$139.00
1942 Wartime Nickel
Etsy
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (762759025), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (762759025), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,000.00
E Pluribus Unum Nickel 1999 Good Condition Monticello On The Back
eBay
$1,000.00
E Pluribus Unum Nickel 1999 Good Condition Monticello On The Back
eBay
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$656.25
1940-S 5C 5FS Jefferson Nickel PCGS MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$656.25
1940-S 5C 5FS Jefferson Nickel PCGS MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68 (762973001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68 (762973001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,062.50
1913-D Type One 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (771105003), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,062.50
1913-D Type One 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (771105003), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1942-P 5C TYPE 2 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (768121002), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1942-P 5C TYPE 2 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (768121002), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (769374005), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (769374005), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,300.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,300.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (765833034), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (765833034), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,312.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67+, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,312.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67+, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$80.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$80.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$812.50
1945-S 5C Jefferson Nickel NGC MS68 (769319001), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$812.50
1945-S 5C Jefferson Nickel NGC MS68 (769319001), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$5,266.29
Error Uncirculated Pcgs MS Mint State Coin Precious Metal Copper Nickel DDR 2005-P
Walmart
Free shipping
$5,266.29
Error Uncirculated Pcgs MS Mint State Coin Precious Metal Copper Nickel DDR 2005-P
Walmart
Free shipping
$92.77
1913 Type-I Buffalo Nickel BU
Walmart
Free shipping
$92.77
1913 Type-I Buffalo Nickel BU
Walmart
Free shipping
$268.03
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel Ms-65 NGC (Beautifully Toned)
Walmart
Free shipping
$268.03
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel Ms-65 NGC (Beautifully Toned)
Walmart
Free shipping
$576.29
1937-S Buffalo Nickel Ms-67 NGC
Walmart
Free shipping
$576.29
1937-S Buffalo Nickel Ms-67 NGC
Walmart
Free shipping
$185.56
1912-S Liberty Head V Nickel VG
Walmart
Free shipping
$185.56
1912-S Liberty Head V Nickel VG
Walmart
Free shipping
$216.48
1938-D Buffalo Nickel Ms-67 NGC
Walmart
Free shipping
$216.48
1938-D Buffalo Nickel Ms-67 NGC
Walmart
Free shipping
$448.44
1929-S Buffalo Nickel Ms-65 Pcgs
Walmart
Free shipping
$448.44
1929-S Buffalo Nickel Ms-65 Pcgs
Walmart
Free shipping

Shop most valuable nickels

Sponsored
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$656.25
1940-S 5C 5FS Jefferson Nickel PCGS MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$656.25
1940-S 5C 5FS Jefferson Nickel PCGS MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68 (762973001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68 (762973001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,062.50
1913-D Type One 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (771105003), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,062.50
1913-D Type One 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (771105003), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1942-P 5C TYPE 2 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (768121002), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1942-P 5C TYPE 2 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (768121002), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (769374005), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (769374005), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,300.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,300.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (765833034), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (765833034), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,312.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67+, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,312.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67+, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$80.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$80.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
$812.50
1945-S 5C Jefferson Nickel NGC MS68 (769319001), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$812.50
1945-S 5C Jefferson Nickel NGC MS68 (769319001), Silver | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$2,187.50
1913-D Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin

Shop most valuable nickels

Sponsored
$35.00
1958 D Nickel Error
Etsy
$35.00
1958 D Nickel Error
Etsy
$799.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel No Date
eBay
Free shipping
$799.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel No Date
eBay
Free shipping
$1,750.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,750.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Indian Head / Buffalo 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Indian Head / Buffalo 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$399.99
1964 Jefferson Five Cent Nickel Denver D Mint Mark
eBay
$399.99
1964 Jefferson Five Cent Nickel Denver D Mint Mark
eBay
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (518894069), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,250.00
1942 5C TYPE 1 Proof Jefferson Nickel NGC PR68 (518894069), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$900.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$900.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$500.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
$500.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
$139.00
1942 Wartime Nickel
Etsy
$139.00
1942 Wartime Nickel
Etsy
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (762759025), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (762759025), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,000.00
E Pluribus Unum Nickel 1999 Good Condition Monticello On The Back
eBay
$1,000.00
E Pluribus Unum Nickel 1999 Good Condition Monticello On The Back
eBay
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$700.00
Very Rare Indian Head / Buffalo Nickel U.S. 5 Cents No Date 1913-1938
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$550.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (Type I)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,187.50
1972 5C FS Jefferson Nickel NGC MS67, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$149.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
Free shipping
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,950.00
Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Cents Nickel (No Date)
eBay
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$1,062.50
1913 Type One 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Buffalo Nickel NGC MS67 (764067001), Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin
$4,380.00
1937 5C Kenneth Bressett Red Book Proof Buffalo Nickel NGC PR68, Copper/Nickel | LCR Coin
LCR Coin

  • Most Valuable Nickels | Now: Most Valuable Nickels

Feedback