Arguably the most legendary of all discontinued Keebler cookies, Magic Middles were a unique and beloved treat. These soft, shortbread-style cookies were filled with a rich fudge or peanut butter ...

Post later replaced it with Smurf Magic Berries (adding marshmallows), but both disappeared by the early ’90s. With the ...

Pop-Tarts Fans Are Begging for the Return of Several 'Forgotten Flavors' originally appeared on Parade. Pop-Tarts flavors ...

Although Hershey is best known for chocolate bars, it also ventured into chewing gum for a time. Bubble Yum Chocolate was one such flavor. While it intrigued chocolate lovers, the unusual combination ...

Popular Ice Cream Chain's New Treat Looks Like Discontinued '80s Favorite originally appeared on Parade. Oreo and Cold Stone ...

"It actually sold pretty well, but was reportedly discontinued because the Mars family in charge at the time were not fans of ...

37."West End. A drink from the '90s, but I can't find evidence of them anywhere." 38."Quints! They were little dolls that ...

Oreo announced that Blueberry Pie Oreos are set to make their triumphant (albeit limited) return after being discontinued in ...

Once proudly stocked in every pantry and lunchbox, these ’70s and ’80s favorites were the life of the grocery aisle. Bright ...

Blueberry Pie Oreos are back after disappearing from shelves in 2017. The graham cracker and blueberry crème cookies will ...

Every item has been rigorously tested by Wirecutter’s experts and vetted by our Deals team. If a sale isn’t up to our ...